Skip to content

94% of Goose & Gander's upsell revenue comes from mystery products

3 min read

This case study walks through how Goose & Gander built its post-purchase upsell almost entirely around mystery products, and what happened to its support queue on day one.

Olly White, Founder of Goose & Gander has had a 10X ROI

  • 10×return on investment
  • £4kin month one
  • £31,689last 365 upsell revenue
  • 10 → 0edit requests a day

10 requests a day down to none

"Before order editing, we used to get about ten requests a day from customers asking to change their order in some way, whether it's an address or product size or different products. Now literally we get none."

— Olly White, Founder, Goose & Gander

Goose & Gander customers have made 2,040 edits, generating £31,689.87 in combined upsell and editing revenue — £15.53 for every edit made.

Solving the problem with Order Editing

Two minutes after a customer orders, Goose & Gander sends an email powered by Order Editing.

1 Customer completes checkout on Shopify
2 Order Editing email · two minutes later — extra space in your package
3 Customers get thirty minutes to add items or fix the order
4 Changes sync to Shopify; order continues to fulfilment

"Two minutes after a customer orders, we send them an email powered by Order Editing and it just sort of tells them you've got extra space in your package for more items. And it gives them thirty minutes to make any changes they need to."

Results the team is tracking

"We found that every time one of our customers used the app, it added an extra fifteen pounds of revenue."

10× return on investment
£31,689 last 365 upsell revenue
£15 extra revenue every time a customer uses the app
10 → 0 edit requests a day

Customers love a mystery product offer

This is the most concentrated upsell programme in our library by a distance, and it's worth understanding why it works so well in this position.

A mystery item asks almost nothing of the customer. There's no product page to read, no fit to consider, no comparison to make against the thing they just bought. The decision is do I want another Goose & Gander item at this price, which is a question they answered thirty seconds ago. Everything that normally slows an upsell down — evaluation, deliberation, second-guessing the size — has been removed.

A mystery tee can be whatever needs to move that week. The offer stays constant while the inventory behind it changes.

  1. Mystery Tee
    27.8%
  2. Mystery Sweatshirt
    26.0%
  3. Mystery Hoodie
    22.9%
  4. Mystery Box — SMALL
    12.0%
  5. Mystery Bottoms
    5.3%
  6. Unisex Nordic Printed Sweatshirt — Burgundy
    3.0%
  7. Goose Necklace
    1.9%

Order Editing creates a better experience for customers, reduces support time, and increases revenue, which is why the team calls it an easy win.

"I would recommend Order Editing to pretty much anyone on Shopify."

Lift AOV. Reduce tickets. Eliminate failed deliveries.

Order Editing turns every order into a revenue and retention engine. Lift AOV at checkout, eliminate 90% of order tickets, and stop failed deliveries before they cost you.

  • Upsells at checkout, post-purchase, one-click, and free shipping thresholds
  • Let customers self-service their orders and reduce editing related tickets by 90%
  • Address Validation that catches bad addresses before they ship
300+ 5 Star Reviews on
90% fewer tickets·$100,000+ upsell revenue·1,600+ Shopify brands

More Customer Stories

View All
Cover image for Trailberg added £1 per order, and £80k ROI, without growing CS
Case Study

Trailberg added £1 per order, and £80k ROI, without growing CS

Jul 22, 2026
Cover image for £340m sportswear group, Castore, achieve a 10.4x ROI and label us a "no-brainer"
Case Study

£340m sportswear group, Castore, achieve a 10.4x ROI and label us a "no-brainer"

Jul 22, 2026
Cover image for Damson Madder makes £3.50 in upsell every time a customer edits their order
Case Study

Damson Madder makes £3.50 in upsell every time a customer edits their order

Jul 22, 2026